Science at the Amusement Park
Ann-Marie Mårtensson-Pendrill, Michael Axelsson
University of Göteborg, Sweden
Ann-Marie.Pendrill@fy.chalmers.se and M.Axelsson@zool.gu.se
For CAL-laborate
What is up? What is down? What is a straight line?
With beating heart we face the unusual movements.
An amusement park is a large hands-on physics laboratory, full of rotating
coordinate systems, free-falling bodies and vector additions.
It gives ample opportunity to experience Newton's laws with eyes, hands and
body. The amusement park Liseberg in Göteborg
is the largest amusement park of Scandinavia. It has long physics traditions -
Albert Einstein gave a talk at Liseberg 1923!
Liseberg has many rides well
suited for physics investigations, using simple equipment, as well as
electronic accelerometers.
Some investigations can easily be adapted
to the local playground.
The heartbeat responds in different ways, both to the various
accelerations and rotations of the body, but also to the thrill already
in the queue. It can be monitored with electrodes on the body and the signal
sent down to ground to be viewed in real time by the classmates.
"Slänggungan" - carousel with swings
A good starting point is the carousel with swings shown in Fig. 1.
As the carousel rotates, the swings hang out from the vertical line,
thereby enabling the chains to provide the force giving the required
centripetal acceleration, while still counteracting the force of gravity.
Take a
moment consider which swings will hang out the most:
the empty ones or the ones loaded with a child or with
an heavy adult! In this situation
students often pick the most heavily-loaded swings.
They watch in amazement as the carousel starts -
all swings (at the same radius)
hang at the same angle, independent of load.
This is an eye-catching example of the equivalence principle: The
angle is determined by the ratio between the centripetal force and the weight.
Since the intertial mass (entering the centripetal force) and the
gravitational mass (entering the weight, mg), are equal, the angle
is independent of the mass.
Eötvös used the rotating earth as a giant merry-go-round by letting
weights of different material balance from a rod suspended as a
torsion
balance. Refined Eötvös experiments are still performed, e.g. at the
Eöt-Wash group at university of Washington, giving lower and lower limits
for possible deviations from the equivalence principle./1/
Some exercises for the reader:
- Estimate the acceleration by looking at the picture.
- What is the apparent weight of a person on the ride.
- Estimate to rotation time, using the information that
the chains are 4.3 m.
Free fall
"Two seconds of weightlessness - can that solve the dieting
problems for the summer", suggested the advertising when
the "Space Shot" was introduced at Liseberg.
Is it possible to be weightless in spite of temptations from
candy floss or waffles with cream? What does weightlessness mean?
Are astronauts weightless because they are so far from the
gravitational field of the earth, as most new students suggest.
(Try asking your group! Follow up by asking them to make a mental picture of
the earth, the moon and the space shuttle.
You could then ask them if and where there is a point
where the gravitational attraction from the moon cancels that of the
earth.)
Or maybe they insist that weightlessness
never occurs, since we cannot escape gravity? Most would, however,
agree that an astronaut experiences weightlessness
if the meatball on a fork hovers in front of the mouth. Meatball, astronaut
and spaceship all fall towards
earth with the same acceleration due to gravity. Similarly,
an astronaut outside the space shuttle does not notice the effect of gravity,
since he falls to earth with exactly the same acceleration as the orbiting
space shuttle.
Many amusement park now offer visitors
the possibility to experience
"two seconds of weightlessness". One example is
the Space Shot, ("Uppskjutet") at Liseberg. After a quick tour up, the seats
are decelerated to a stop before starting the free fall.
Following the fall it
lands softly on an pressurized air. (The Free Fall e.g. at Gröna Lund
in Stockholm, is instead decelerated by eddy currents produced by strong
magnets.) The experience of weightlessness can be enhanced by taking along a
small mug of water (1 cm of water is quite enough) and watch the water falling
(don't pick a seat with headwind!).
In the right conditions, the water seems to move slowly upward. Try it!
Figure 2: Accelerometer data for the space shot.
The vertical axis is chosen so that standing on the
ground gives "-1g".
From the figure we see that the rider experiences about 3.5 g for a short
moment at the start and after 1.5 s of approximate weightlessness
experiences 2.5g, the 2.0g etc during the bouncing off the pressurised air.
|
|
Often, the accelerations in an amusement park instead cause
the rider to be significantly heavier than usual.
"The Space Shot's emphasis is on the sudden blast upward from the
bottom." /2/
Fig 2 shows
accelerometer data for the space shot, obtained with a
"calculator based laboratory" (CBL) connected to a graphical
calculator. The data can also be used to estimate the
velocity at various points of the ride, and even the position. It is a
good exercise in numerical sensitivity; The resolution of the accelerometer is
about 0.013g. What is the resulting
uncertainty in the position after the ride
(where, of course, we know that the rider is safely back to the starting
point)?
|
A more visual accelerometer is provided by a slinky.
Fig. 3 shows three slinkys, one unloaded, one stretched by external
forces, and one hanging free. Note how the spacing of the
turns of the hanging slinky increases with the increasing load from the lower
turns.
A few exercises for the reader:
- What do you expect the slinky to look like at the top?
- How long would the slinky be with half the number of turns?
(more suitable to take along on a ride!)?
- How do you expect a (half)
slinky to look at the start of the "Space Shot"
There are several versions of eye-catching towers in different parks.
E.g., the "Turbo Drop" /2/ (available
e.g. at Liseberg where it takes the rider
100m above sea level - how far away is the horizon?)
lets the rider fall with 2g, causing an apparent
"upward fall" of the water (don't hold the mug under you chin!).
The "Free fall" at Gröna Lund in Stockholm, on the other hand,
really is a free fall
following a long wait at the top. Thus, the water
should be expected to remain
in the mug, but it doesn't. Biology catches up with the physics
in the form or a "Moro Reflex", familiar to parents of small children:
A baby under sudden moves attempts to cling on to the mother,
to avoid falling. Similary, the rider feeling the seat drop, for an instant
raises the hand, giving the water a small push upwards. /3/
With the heart upside down
In an amusement park, the body is exposed to a large variety of unusual
movements. How does it respond? One obvious measure is the pulse.
For attractions, like the "Space shot",
wher the largest accelerations happen within
time scales of seconds or shorter, the resolution of the heart beat is somewhat
low. The slow pendulum shown in Fig. 4 is ideal for studying the reactions of
the heart. Fig. 5. shows accelerometer data from the ride
(with the accelerometer pointing straight down to the seat
throughout the ride).
As seen from the data, the swing goes from one side to the other in about
10 seconds, until it finally makes it slowly over the top and
completes a few full turns. The baroreceptors in the body sense the
higher pressure in the head.
Standing on the ground, the observer can watch the
heartbeat dropping significantly about 2 seconds after the rider passed
the top.
One example is shown in Fig. 6. (Note: Not all rides are identical and the
accelerometer data in Fig.5 were not recorded at the same time as the
heartbeat in Fig. 6.)
Exercises for the reader:
- Using the accelerometer data, estimate the maximum
angle at every turn.
- How does the period depend on the amplitude?
- The distance from the center is about 12 m. What would be the period of
a mathematical pendulum of this length? What would be the length of a
mathematical pendulum with the period of this attraction?
The Roller Coaster
If you visit Liseberg, you must not miss the "Lisebergbanan".
The train is
first pulled up to 65 m over sea level, giving a good
view over the city of Göteborg
and over the building site for the new Science Center "Universeum",
to be inaugurated in June 2001. The train takes
you on a 2.7 km and 2.5 minute ride, to a large extent
using the natural hills in the park,
to a lowest point of 20 m and a maximum speed of 95 km/h.
A roller coaster is a prime example of the energy principle, where
the potential energy provided as you pass the highest point is all you have
to take you round the track. How well is the energy conserved?
A visual indication is provided by the nearby "Hangover", where the train
makes a return trip on the same track. Before starting on the return journey,
the train reaches nearly is original height, before being pulled the
last few meters to the top.
A roller coaster also provides good examples of vector addition, as the train
slopes and curves in different directions.
In several places the tracks are built imitate the free fall parabola.
The acceleration can be measured
in several different ways. A "horizontal accelerometer" is provided by a little
mass on a string, e.g. a Liseberg rabbit from one of the shops. It will bounce
considerably, and needs to be stopped now and then, e.g. passing over the top
of a hill. Watch the angle the rabbit makes to the track!
(Remember, you and the rabbit undergo the same acceleration, but the rabbit
hanging from the string
does not feel the "normal force" from the seat.)
The slinky can again be taken along as a vertical accelerometer, or more
precise data can be recorded using electronic devices.
Exercises for the reader
- Neglecting friction, what speed would you expect from 45 m
height difference?
- At every instant all parts of the train has the same speed.
Nevertheless, the ride in the front, back and middle are different. Why?
In which seat will you feel the lightest? The heaviest?
- How do you expect the "rabbit-on-a-string" to hang as the train
accelerates down a hill? As it turns to the left?
- Is the reading from a vertical accelerometer sufficient to
provide information about "g-forces"?
Before leaving the park
Visit one of the shops and get a helium balloon (take the smallest you can
find) for experiments during the trip home. It works best in the large space
provided in a bus, but works reasonably well also in car.
What happens to the balloon as the vehicle starts? As it turns?
As it brakes in front of a traffic light?
Using an amusement park in courses
Liseberg has been used in the introductory physics course for
students in
the educational programme "Problem Solving in Natural Sciences"
at Göteborg university since its start in 1995. The Liseberg visit
takes place within their first month at the university. Each of the 5-6 groups
of about 6 students is assigned 3 different attractions of different types,
with the task to describe the motion, figure out e.g.
how energy is provided and,
where applicable, the point where the rider would
feel the heaviest and the lightest (how heavy? how light?)
In some cases detailed data was made available by the amusement park.
If a force is worked out with wrong sign it become immediately obvious
when confronted with the experience of the body.
The observations and results from each group
are then presented and discussed with the rest of the class
in a session of about 3 hours, usually very enjoyable.
After the first year, more systematic instructions and information were
presented on the WWW, with help enlisted from a few
students in a summer project, paid by the science faculty at
Göteborg university.
The pages have since
been revised and extended, in view of experiences gained
from working with the material in subsequent courses, and, of course, as new
attractions have been added to the park.
These pages, available at www.science.gu.se/slagkraft/, are now used by many schools
from various parts of Sweden
in their preparation for excursions to Liseberg.
During the year 2000, the "FRN"
provided support to enable graduate students to
direct visits for school classes - and giving all of
us easier access to children's thoughts.
During a visit to an amusement park the equations come alive.
Second derivatives are felt throughout the body.
The block on the inclined plane is replaced by
a train in the slope of a roller coaster and
"Gedanken experiments" from the textbooks
can be realised in one of the most attractive
hands-on laboratories available.
Acknowledgements
Liseberg kindly let us use the "Aerovarvet" attraction, and also
provided ride tickets for
the pupils' experiments with water mugs, rabbits on strings or electronic
measuring equipment.
The funds provided by FRN were supplemented by
contributions from the "strategic funds" of
the science faculty, where the project was developed in a group
including also Margareta Wallin-Pettersson, Elisabeth Strömberg and
Marie Delin Oscarsson and the students
Susanne Svensson, Anna Holmberg, Sara Bagge, Manda Gustavsson,
Åsa Haglund and Sara Mattson.
Further, we would like to
express our appreciation of the loan of equipment from
Texas Instruments and Zenit läromedel, and assistance
from Bengt Åhlander and Jan-Erik Woldmar with
the programs for the calculator.
Richard Pendrill took the Aerovarvet and the roller coaster pictures.
- The Eot-Wash
group at University of Washington:
http://mist.npl.washington.edu:80/eotwash/
- http://www.s-spower.com/,
Manufacturer Information about the
"Space Shot" and the
Turbo Drop
- See the presentation of experiments at Gröna Lund
at http://www.physto.se/gronalund/
http://www.science.gu.se/slagkraft/
http://www.fy.chalmers.se/LISEBERG/callab.html
Ann-Marie Pendrill
is professor of physics at Göteborg university, and a guest professor at
Högskolan i Skövde, Michael Axelsson is assistant professor at the
department of zoology
17 october 2000
AMP